Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice’s stage sensation became a full-on widescreen musical epic at a time when they were extinct, yielding an Oscar for Best Original Song (the new “You Must Love Me”) and four additional nominations. Madonna silenced skeptics with her impassioned performance as the 1940s actress-turned-First Lady of Argentina; Banderas scored his first Golden Globe nomination as the fiery one-man chorus opining—and singing—about her rise and rise.